Some states examine voting system software, in particular the source code that provides instructions to the voting system hardware--and keep a copy in escrow--as part of that state's requirements for certification of the voting system.
Voting systems are often modified and updated. A state may
require escrow to help provide a framework for ensuring that the state-approved
version of a system is the one being used in actual elections locally. A
prohibition on unauthorized versions of voting system software may not prevent their
use, but it should provide a legal guideline which vendors – and local
jurisdictions – must follow.
Such requirements vary from state to state; the requirements may not be
contained in statute but instead in rules promulgated by the chief
election official. For example, California's former Secretary of State
was able to task the voting systems technology advisory board with
review of a particular voting system component because of a rule he
established that voting system vendors must escrow source code not only
with a third-party escrow facility but also with the Secretary of State. Some states establish that the software must be disclosed in
certain circumstances. The conditions for such disclosure vary. In most cases, this means the state is required, or reserves
the right, to examine the software to try to determine if it functions as the
vendor has represented. Although the vendor must still provide the code in
order to accomplish this, it is not the same as an escrow provision. For example, a state that requires disclosure
of the software for the purposes of initial testing for certification may just leave
it at that, and not require re-testing for every modification. In such cases,
local jurisdictions could well be using different versions of the system
software than that which was originally tested and approved, and no “approved
version” would be escrowed. States for which we have found escrow (or related) provisions include: Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Minnesota, Missouri, New York, North Carolina, Texas, Utah, Wisconsin and Washington. Please see the attached PDF document "Escrow Provisions" for details and links. There may also be states considering such provisions in pending legislation. We welcome learning about those bills as well. Please write to observer@verifiedvoting.org if you have information to share about such provisions. Thanks go to Joe Hall for his early review of this draft document and helpful comments.
|